Critique a board paper that argues for an acquisition
Scenario
Context: You are a non-executive director at a mid-sized logistics group. The chief executive has circulated a board paper recommending the purchase of a regional courier firm for 40 million euros. The board votes next week. Problem: The paper argues: "We have already spent 3 million euros on due diligence, so walking away would waste that money. Synergies of 8 million euros a year are expected, based on the best year of each business. Our acquisition of a parcel firm in 2021 was a great success, so this one will be too. The courier's founder, a respected figure, assures us the business is growing. Competitors are making acquisitions; if we don't act, we will fall behind." The paper does not include the courier's accounts for the last two years. Constraints: You have 15 minutes to speak at the board meeting. The chief executive is a strong advocate and has a good track record. You cannot commission new analysis before the vote, but you can ask for documents. Expected deliverable: Present your critique in 5 points: 1) each argument in the paper and how much weight it can bear; 2) the information that is missing; 3) the questions you will ask at the meeting, in order of priority; 4) the conditions under which you would vote in favour; 5) how you will raise your concerns without undermining the chief executive.
Targeted skills
Context & stakes
Board papers are written to persuade, and a strong chief executive can carry a room. This logistics group's directors must vote on a 40-million-euro acquisition next week, on the basis of a paper that mixes past spending, projected synergies, a previous success and the reassurance of the target's founder. A non-executive director has a short slot to speak.
The case assesses the ability to take a persuasive document apart argument by argument, to say precisely how much each one supports the conclusion, and to identify what is missing. Assessors also look at whether the questions are well prioritised for a 15-minute slot, whether the conditions for a yes vote are concrete, and whether concerns are raised in a way that keeps the board working together.
Quoting each argument briefly before judging it keeps the critique fair. Ending with conditions rather than a flat no gives the board a way forward. Non-executive directors, strategy and finance professionals, investment committee members and senior managers who review proposals will find the case useful.
More Pensée critique case studies
- Assess the evidence in a vendor's customer case studyFundamental
- Investigate a sharp rise in a customer satisfaction scoreAdvanced
- Review a claim that a new shift pattern cut staff absencesFundamental
- Advise on a hiring test that is said to predict performanceAdvanced
- Apply a travel expense policy to four claimsFundamental
- Challenge a project timeline estimate before a client commitmentAdvanced
Original questions designed by CodeDuel. CodeDuel is not affiliated with any publisher or certification body mentioned; certification names and trademarks belong to their respective owners and are used only to indicate the area covered. Report content
