Apply a travel expense policy to four claims
Scenario
Context: You work in the finance team of an engineering consultancy. The travel policy states: "Business-class flights are reimbursed only if the flight lasts more than six hours. Hotel costs above 150 euros per night are reimbursed if the stay was approved by a director in advance. Taxi costs are reimbursed unless a company shuttle was available." Problem: Four claims arrive. Ana flew business class on a five-hour flight. Ben stayed in a 180-euro hotel, approved by his director after the trip. Chloe took a taxi to the airport at 5 am; the shuttle starts at 7 am. Dev flew business class on a nine-hour flight and stayed in a 140-euro hotel without approval. A colleague says Ben's hotel should be paid because "the policy only lists one way to get reimbursed, it doesn't forbid others". Constraints: You must apply the policy as written. Each decision must be explainable to the employee in one or two sentences. Disputed cases go to the finance director, who expects a clear reading of the text. Expected deliverable: Answer in 3 points: 1) your decision for each claim, with the rule that supports it; 2) your view on the colleague's argument about Ben's hotel; 3) a rewording of the hotel rule that would remove the dispute.
Targeted skills
Context & stakes
Company policies often look clear until a disputed claim arrives. A finance officer at an engineering consultancy must process four travel claims, one of which has already split the team. Each decision will be questioned if it does not follow closely from the policy's wording.
What is assessed is the exact application of written conditions: knowing what a rule requires, what it allows and what it leaves unsaid. Assessors check that each decision names the rule behind it, that the colleague's argument is examined on its logic rather than dismissed, and that the proposed rewording settles the dispute without creating new gaps. Answers that decide on fairness instead of the text miss the brief.
Reading each sentence of the policy slowly, word by word, prevents most errors. Testing the new wording on all four claims shows whether it works. Finance officers, HR administrators, internal auditors and managers who apply procedures every day are the intended audience.
More Pensée critique case studies
- Advise on a hiring test that is said to predict performanceAdvanced
- Critique a board paper that argues for an acquisitionExpert
- Challenge a project timeline estimate before a client commitmentAdvanced
- Decide whether to roll out a store layout pilot across the chainExpert
- Evaluate a plan to rank sales staff by total revenueAdvanced
- Reconcile two conflicting figures before a regulator deadlineExpert
Original questions designed by CodeDuel. CodeDuel is not affiliated with any publisher or certification body mentioned; certification names and trademarks belong to their respective owners and are used only to indicate the area covered. Report content
