Review a claim that a new shift pattern cut staff absences
Scenario
Context: You are an operations analyst at a food processing plant with 350 staff. In May, the plant manager introduced a new shift pattern on two of its four production lines. He now wants to roll it out to all lines in October. Problem: His summary reads: "Absence on lines 1 and 2 fell from 6.1% in April to 4.2% in June and July. The new shifts work." Last year, absence across the plant was 5.9% in April and 4.4% in June and July. Lines 3 and 4, which kept the old pattern, recorded 4.6% in June and July this year. Lines 1 and 2 also received new rest-room facilities in May. Constraints: The manager presents to the board next Tuesday. No new data will be collected before then. Your answer must fit on one page and be readable by non-specialists. Expected deliverable: Answer in 4 points: 1) what the figures allow you to say; 2) what they do not allow you to say, and why; 3) what information you would ask for before October; 4) your advice on the rollout.
Targeted skills
Context & stakes
A plant manager is pleased with a drop in absence after changing shift patterns on two production lines, and plans to extend the change across the site. The figures in his summary are accurate, but a board decision based on them needs a careful reading of the evidence. The analyst has a few days and no new data.
Assessors look at how well the candidate uses all the figures provided, and whether alternative explanations are put forward with care. Credit goes to answers that separate what is established from what is merely possible, ask for information that would genuinely settle the question, and give advice that the board can act on. Dismissing the new shifts outright is no more convincing than endorsing them.
It pays to read every number in the scenario and ask what each one adds. Keeping the advice proportionate to the evidence makes it easier for a busy board to accept. Operations analysts, HR business partners, plant managers and anyone who reports on the effect of workplace changes will find this case relevant.
More Pensée critique case studies
- Evaluate a plan to rank sales staff by total revenueAdvanced
- Reconcile two conflicting figures before a regulator deadlineExpert
- Investigate a sharp rise in a customer satisfaction scoreAdvanced
- Critique a board paper that argues for an acquisitionExpert
- Advise on a hiring test that is said to predict performanceAdvanced
- Decide whether to roll out a store layout pilot across the chainExpert
Original questions designed by CodeDuel. CodeDuel is not affiliated with any publisher or certification body mentioned; certification names and trademarks belong to their respective owners and are used only to indicate the area covered. Report content
