Assess the evidence in a vendor's customer case study
Scenario
Context: You are a procurement manager at an insurance company. Your claims team is considering a document-processing tool, and the vendor has sent a case study about one of its clients. Problem: The case study says: "After adopting our tool, Northgate Mutual cut claim processing time by 40%." It shows average processing times of 10 days before and 6 days after. The text also mentions that Northgate hired 12 additional claims handlers during the same quarter and simplified its claim forms. The vendor chose which client to feature. Your claims director says the case study "proves the tool works". Constraints: You meet the vendor in two days for 30 minutes. You cannot contact Northgate without the vendor's agreement. The decision will be taken by the claims director and the finance director. Expected deliverable: Present your analysis in 3 points: 1) what the case study shows and what it does not show; 2) the questions you will put to the vendor; 3) what evidence you would accept as convincing before recommending the tool.
Targeted skills
Context & stakes
Vendors often support their sales pitch with a success story from a satisfied client. Here, a document-processing vendor reports a large drop in claim handling time at an insurer, and the claims director is already persuaded. The procurement manager needs to judge what the story actually demonstrates before meeting the vendor.
The evaluation focuses on whether the candidate reads the case study closely, works out what it can and cannot demonstrate, and turns these observations into precise questions. Strong answers specify the kind of evidence that would be persuasive rather than simply asking for more information. A clear distinction between what the vendor can show and what the buyer must check for itself also counts.
Taking each claim in the case study separately keeps the analysis clear. Writing down what you would do with each answer from the vendor makes the questions sharper. The case is aimed at procurement managers, project leads, operations managers and anyone who has to evaluate a supplier's evidence.
More Pensée critique case studies
- Challenge a project timeline estimate before a client commitmentAdvanced
- Decide whether to roll out a store layout pilot across the chainExpert
- Evaluate a plan to rank sales staff by total revenueAdvanced
- Reconcile two conflicting figures before a regulator deadlineExpert
- Investigate a sharp rise in a customer satisfaction scoreAdvanced
- Critique a board paper that argues for an acquisitionExpert
Original questions designed by CodeDuel. CodeDuel is not affiliated with any publisher or certification body mentioned; certification names and trademarks belong to their respective owners and are used only to indicate the area covered. Report content
