Apply a travel expense policy to four claims
Context: You work in the finance team of an engineering consultancy. The travel policy states: "Business-class flights are reimbursed only if the flight lasts more than six hours. Hotel costs above 150 euros per night are reimbursed if the stay was approved by a director in advance. Taxi costs are reimbursed unless a company shuttle was available." Problem: Four claims arrive. Ana flew business class on a five-hour flight. Ben stayed in a 180-euro hotel, approved by his director after the trip. Chloe took a taxi to the airport at 5 am; the shuttle starts at 7 am. Dev flew business class on a nine-hour flight and stayed in a 140-euro hotel without approval. A colleague says Ben's hotel should be paid because "the policy only lists one way to get reimbursed, it doesn't forbid others". Constraints: You must apply the policy as written. Each decision must be explainable to the employee in one or two sentences. Disputed cases go to the finance director, who expects a clear reading of the text. Expected deliverable: Answer in 3 points: 1) your decision for each claim, with the rule that supports it; 2) your view on the colleague's argument about Ben's hotel; 3) a rewording of the hotel rule that would remove the dispute.
logicdeductionfinance+1