Pensée critique case studies

10 Pensée critique case studies available. Levels: fundamental (3), advanced (4), expert (3).
FundamentalPensée critique

Apply a travel expense policy to four claims

Context: You work in the finance team of an engineering consultancy. The travel policy states: "Business-class flights are reimbursed only if the flight lasts more than six hours. Hotel costs above 150 euros per night are reimbursed if the stay was approved by a director in advance. Taxi costs are reimbursed unless a company shuttle was available." Problem: Four claims arrive. Ana flew business class on a five-hour flight. Ben stayed in a 180-euro hotel, approved by his director after the trip. Chloe took a taxi to the airport at 5 am; the shuttle starts at 7 am. Dev flew business class on a nine-hour flight and stayed in a 140-euro hotel without approval. A colleague says Ben's hotel should be paid because "the policy only lists one way to get reimbursed, it doesn't forbid others". Constraints: You must apply the policy as written. Each decision must be explainable to the employee in one or two sentences. Disputed cases go to the finance director, who expects a clear reading of the text. Expected deliverable: Answer in 3 points: 1) your decision for each claim, with the rule that supports it; 2) your view on the colleague's argument about Ben's hotel; 3) a rewording of the hotel rule that would remove the dispute.

logicdeductionfinance+1
FundamentalPensée critique

Assess the evidence in a vendor's customer case study

Context: You are a procurement manager at an insurance company. Your claims team is considering a document-processing tool, and the vendor has sent a case study about one of its clients. Problem: The case study says: "After adopting our tool, Northgate Mutual cut claim processing time by 40%." It shows average processing times of 10 days before and 6 days after. The text also mentions that Northgate hired 12 additional claims handlers during the same quarter and simplified its claim forms. The vendor chose which client to feature. Your claims director says the case study "proves the tool works". Constraints: You meet the vendor in two days for 30 minutes. You cannot contact Northgate without the vendor's agreement. The decision will be taken by the claims director and the finance director. Expected deliverable: Present your analysis in 3 points: 1) what the case study shows and what it does not show; 2) the questions you will put to the vendor; 3) what evidence you would accept as convincing before recommending the tool.

evidenceprocurementsources+1
FundamentalPensée critique

Review a claim that a new shift pattern cut staff absences

Context: You are an operations analyst at a food processing plant with 350 staff. In May, the plant manager introduced a new shift pattern on two of its four production lines. He now wants to roll it out to all lines in October. Problem: His summary reads: "Absence on lines 1 and 2 fell from 6.1% in April to 4.2% in June and July. The new shifts work." Last year, absence across the plant was 5.9% in April and 4.4% in June and July. Lines 3 and 4, which kept the old pattern, recorded 4.6% in June and July this year. Lines 1 and 2 also received new rest-room facilities in May. Constraints: The manager presents to the board next Tuesday. No new data will be collected before then. Your answer must fit on one page and be readable by non-specialists. Expected deliverable: Answer in 4 points: 1) what the figures allow you to say; 2) what they do not allow you to say, and why; 3) what information you would ask for before October; 4) your advice on the rollout.

data analysisoperationsHR+1
AdvancedPensée critique

Advise on a hiring test that is said to predict performance

Context: You are a talent acquisition lead at a logistics company that hires about 200 warehouse supervisors a year. A consultant has sold the company an online reasoning test and recommends rejecting candidates who score below 60 out of 100. Problem: The consultant's report says: "Among the 40 supervisors hired last year who took the test, those scoring above 80 had better first-year ratings than those scoring 60 to 80." Only candidates scoring above 60 were hired. First-year ratings are given by line managers, who could see test scores. The HR director wants to raise the cut-off to 70 to "hire only the best". Constraints: Hiring for the peak season starts in six weeks. The company already struggles to fill supervisor roles in two regions. Any change to the cut-off must be explainable to candidates who ask why they were rejected. Expected deliverable: Present your advice in 5 points: 1) what the consultant's finding shows; 2) its limits as evidence for the cut-off; 3) the risks of raising the cut-off to 70; 4) how the company could test the value of the test over the coming year; 5) your recommendation for the peak-season hiring.

recruitmentstatisticsevidence+1
AdvancedPensée critique

Challenge a project timeline estimate before a client commitment

Context: You are a project management officer at a software services firm. A client wants a new booking system, and the account manager must give a delivery date in a meeting on Friday. Problem: The project team estimates eight weeks, broken down task by task. The team is confident: "We know this kind of system well." Over the past three years, the firm delivered five similar booking systems. They were estimated at seven to nine weeks and took between 12 and 16 weeks. The account manager wants to quote eight weeks to win the contract against a competitor who has promised ten. Constraints: The contract includes a penalty of 1,500 euros per week of delay. The team cannot start before the 1st of next month. The account manager has the final say on the quote. You have one hour with the team before Friday. Expected deliverable: Present your approach in 4 points: 1) what the team's estimate and the past projects each tell you; 2) how you would use your hour with the team; 3) the date or range you would advise the account manager to quote, with the risk in euros; 4) what you would put in place so that future estimates improve.

project managementestimationdecision-making+1
AdvancedPensée critique

Evaluate a plan to rank sales staff by total revenue

Context: You are an HR business partner at a medical equipment distributor with 24 sales representatives. The sales director wants to publish a monthly ranking of reps by total revenue and pay a bonus to the top five. Problem: The reps cover very different territories: some serve large city hospitals, others rural clinics. Six reps joined less than a year ago and inherited territories with few existing clients. Two reps handle a single national account worth a quarter of company revenue. Last year's top five were all city reps with more than five years in the company. The sales director says: "Revenue is the only fair measure. Numbers don't lie." Constraints: The scheme must start next quarter. Payroll can only handle one bonus calculation per month. The sales director must remain the owner of the scheme. Any measure used must come from data already in the CRM. Expected deliverable: Present your response in 4 points: 1) what a revenue ranking would measure in this company; 2) the risks of the proposed scheme, including effects on behaviour; 3) an alternative measure or design that uses existing data; 4) how you would present your view to the sales director.

metricssales managementfairness+1
AdvancedPensée critique

Investigate a sharp rise in a customer satisfaction score

Context: You are a customer insight analyst at a regional energy supplier. In March, the company replaced its email satisfaction survey with a short text message sent right after a call to customer service ends. Problem: The average satisfaction score rose from 6.8 to 8.1 out of 10 between the first and second quarter. The response rate rose from 4% to 19%. Formal complaints to the energy ombudsman stayed at the same level. The customer service director wants to announce the improvement in the annual report and credit her team's new training programme, which started in February. Constraints: The annual report text must be submitted in three weeks. You cannot run a parallel email survey before then. The board is sensitive to claims that could later be challenged by the regulator. Expected deliverable: Answer in 4 points: 1) the possible explanations for the rise in the score; 2) the evidence in the scenario that supports or weakens each; 3) the checks you can carry out within three weeks; 4) the wording you would recommend for the annual report.

surveyscustomer experiencemeasurement+1
ExpertPensée critique

Critique a board paper that argues for an acquisition

Context: You are a non-executive director at a mid-sized logistics group. The chief executive has circulated a board paper recommending the purchase of a regional courier firm for 40 million euros. The board votes next week. Problem: The paper argues: "We have already spent 3 million euros on due diligence, so walking away would waste that money. Synergies of 8 million euros a year are expected, based on the best year of each business. Our acquisition of a parcel firm in 2021 was a great success, so this one will be too. The courier's founder, a respected figure, assures us the business is growing. Competitors are making acquisitions; if we don't act, we will fall behind." The paper does not include the courier's accounts for the last two years. Constraints: You have 15 minutes to speak at the board meeting. The chief executive is a strong advocate and has a good track record. You cannot commission new analysis before the vote, but you can ask for documents. Expected deliverable: Present your critique in 5 points: 1) each argument in the paper and how much weight it can bear; 2) the information that is missing; 3) the questions you will ask at the meeting, in order of priority; 4) the conditions under which you would vote in favour; 5) how you will raise your concerns without undermining the chief executive.

argument evaluationstrategyfinance+2
ExpertPensée critique

Decide whether to roll out a store layout pilot across the chain

Context: You are head of strategy at a home goods retailer with 60 stores. A new store layout was piloted for three months in eight stores, and the operations director wants approval to roll it out everywhere at a cost of 90,000 euros per store. Problem: In the pilot stores, sales rose 9% compared with the same three months last year. Across the other 52 stores, sales rose 3%. The pilot stores were chosen by regional managers, who picked "stores with strong teams that would make the pilot work". Staff in the pilot stores knew they were being watched and received extra training. Two pilot stores are in shopping centres that opened new car parks during the pilot. Constraints: The board meets in four weeks. The budget for the year allows up to 20 stores to be refitted. Refitting a store closes it for one week. The operations director has publicly backed the layout and the regional managers are keen. Expected deliverable: Present your analysis in 5 points: 1) what the pilot results show; 2) how far the 6-point gap can be expected to hold across the chain; 3) the decision you would recommend to the board for this year; 4) how you would design the next stage so that its results are more reliable; 5) how you would handle the operations director and regional managers.

retailexperiment designdecision-making+2
ExpertPensée critique

Reconcile two conflicting figures before a regulator deadline

Context: You are a reporting manager at a consumer credit company. Each quarter, the company must report to the financial regulator the number of customers more than 90 days late on payments. The report is due in 48 hours. Problem: The risk team's report shows 4,210 customers more than 90 days late. The collections team's report shows 3,650. The risk report counts from the payment due date; the collections report counts from the date the first reminder letter is sent, usually 10 days later. The risk report includes customers who have agreed a repayment plan; collections excludes them. Last quarter, the company reported the collections figure. The chief financial officer asks you which number is "right". Constraints: The regulator's guidance defines lateness from the contractual due date and says nothing about repayment plans. The report cannot be submitted late. Any change from last quarter's method must be explained to the regulator. You can work with both teams for one day. Expected deliverable: Present your approach in 5 points: 1) the reasons for the gap between the two figures; 2) which figure, or which corrected figure, you would report, and why; 3) what you would check with each team during your day; 4) how you would handle the difference with last quarter's report; 5) what you would change so this does not happen again.

data qualitycompliancereporting+1

Original questions designed by CodeDuel. CodeDuel is not affiliated with any publisher or certification body mentioned; certification names and trademarks belong to their respective owners and are used only to indicate the area covered. Report content

    Pensée critique case studies: 10 scenarios | CodeDuel