Pensée critiqueExpert

Reconcile two conflicting figures before a regulator deadline

Scenario

Context: You are a reporting manager at a consumer credit company. Each quarter, the company must report to the financial regulator the number of customers more than 90 days late on payments. The report is due in 48 hours. Problem: The risk team's report shows 4,210 customers more than 90 days late. The collections team's report shows 3,650. The risk report counts from the payment due date; the collections report counts from the date the first reminder letter is sent, usually 10 days later. The risk report includes customers who have agreed a repayment plan; collections excludes them. Last quarter, the company reported the collections figure. The chief financial officer asks you which number is "right". Constraints: The regulator's guidance defines lateness from the contractual due date and says nothing about repayment plans. The report cannot be submitted late. Any change from last quarter's method must be explained to the regulator. You can work with both teams for one day. Expected deliverable: Present your approach in 5 points: 1) the reasons for the gap between the two figures; 2) which figure, or which corrected figure, you would report, and why; 3) what you would check with each team during your day; 4) how you would handle the difference with last quarter's report; 5) what you would change so this does not happen again.

Targeted skills

data qualitycompliancereportingproblem solving

Context & stakes

Two internal reports giving different answers to the same question are a common headache, and a serious one when a regulator is waiting. At this consumer credit company, the risk and collections teams count late customers differently, and the report is due in two days. The chief financial officer wants to know which number to send.

This case tests how clearly the candidate explains the gap from the facts given, how the choice of figure is tied to the regulator's own definition, and how the inconsistency with last quarter is handled. Assessors value a realistic plan for the day with both teams and lasting changes to reporting. Answers that pick a number without explaining what it measures fall short.

Writing each difference in definition next to its likely effect on the count makes the reasoning easy to follow. Keeping the answer short and organised helps the chief financial officer act on it. Reporting managers, compliance officers, finance controllers and data analysts in regulated industries are the intended audience.

More Pensée critique case studies

See all Pensée critique case studies

Original questions designed by CodeDuel. CodeDuel is not affiliated with any publisher or certification body mentioned; certification names and trademarks belong to their respective owners and are used only to indicate the area covered. Report content