Evaluate a plan to rank sales staff by total revenue
Scenario
Context: You are an HR business partner at a medical equipment distributor with 24 sales representatives. The sales director wants to publish a monthly ranking of reps by total revenue and pay a bonus to the top five. Problem: The reps cover very different territories: some serve large city hospitals, others rural clinics. Six reps joined less than a year ago and inherited territories with few existing clients. Two reps handle a single national account worth a quarter of company revenue. Last year's top five were all city reps with more than five years in the company. The sales director says: "Revenue is the only fair measure. Numbers don't lie." Constraints: The scheme must start next quarter. Payroll can only handle one bonus calculation per month. The sales director must remain the owner of the scheme. Any measure used must come from data already in the CRM. Expected deliverable: Present your response in 4 points: 1) what a revenue ranking would measure in this company; 2) the risks of the proposed scheme, including effects on behaviour; 3) an alternative measure or design that uses existing data; 4) how you would present your view to the sales director.
Targeted skills
Context & stakes
Ranking employees by a single number appeals to managers because it looks objective. This distributor's sales director wants to rank reps by revenue and reward the top five, but the reps work under very different conditions. The HR business partner must respond before the scheme starts next quarter.
The case rewards candidates who explain what the proposed figure really captures in this particular sales force, anticipate how people will react to the scheme, and propose a design that fits the stated constraints. Assessors look for a fair alternative built on data that already exists, and for a way of making the case to a director who is attached to his idea. Purely theoretical objections earn less than practical ones.
Thinking about how each type of rep would experience the ranking helps reveal its effects. Ending with a proposal the director could own makes the answer useful. HR business partners, sales managers, reward specialists and analysts who design performance measures will recognise the situation.
More Pensée critique case studies
- Review a claim that a new shift pattern cut staff absencesFundamental
- Reconcile two conflicting figures before a regulator deadlineExpert
- Apply a travel expense policy to four claimsFundamental
- Critique a board paper that argues for an acquisitionExpert
- Assess the evidence in a vendor's customer case studyFundamental
- Decide whether to roll out a store layout pilot across the chainExpert
Original questions designed by CodeDuel. CodeDuel is not affiliated with any publisher or certification body mentioned; certification names and trademarks belong to their respective owners and are used only to indicate the area covered. Report content
