Decide whether to roll out a store layout pilot across the chain
Scenario
Context: You are head of strategy at a home goods retailer with 60 stores. A new store layout was piloted for three months in eight stores, and the operations director wants approval to roll it out everywhere at a cost of 90,000 euros per store. Problem: In the pilot stores, sales rose 9% compared with the same three months last year. Across the other 52 stores, sales rose 3%. The pilot stores were chosen by regional managers, who picked "stores with strong teams that would make the pilot work". Staff in the pilot stores knew they were being watched and received extra training. Two pilot stores are in shopping centres that opened new car parks during the pilot. Constraints: The board meets in four weeks. The budget for the year allows up to 20 stores to be refitted. Refitting a store closes it for one week. The operations director has publicly backed the layout and the regional managers are keen. Expected deliverable: Present your analysis in 5 points: 1) what the pilot results show; 2) how far the 6-point gap can be expected to hold across the chain; 3) the decision you would recommend to the board for this year; 4) how you would design the next stage so that its results are more reliable; 5) how you would handle the operations director and regional managers.
Targeted skills
Context & stakes
A pilot that beats the rest of the chain makes a strong case for rolling out, and the people who ran it are eager to go further. This home goods retailer tested a new layout in eight stores and saw a clear sales gain. The operations director wants a full rollout, a decision that would cost several million euros.
The case evaluates whether the candidate examines how the pilot was set up, checks what else changed in the pilot stores, and turns this into a decision that fits the year's budget and constraints. A next stage designed to produce trustworthy results is expected, along with handling of the people involved that preserves their commitment. Strong answers neither reject the layout nor accept the pilot at face value.
Listing what made the pilot stores different from the others, before discussing the layout, gives the analysis a solid base. A recommendation that uses this year's budget to learn as well as to act will be easier to defend. Heads of strategy, retail operations managers, analysts and consultants who evaluate pilots and rollouts will find the case relevant.
More Pensée critique case studies
- Review a claim that a new shift pattern cut staff absencesFundamental
- Advise on a hiring test that is said to predict performanceAdvanced
- Apply a travel expense policy to four claimsFundamental
- Challenge a project timeline estimate before a client commitmentAdvanced
- Assess the evidence in a vendor's customer case studyFundamental
- Evaluate a plan to rank sales staff by total revenueAdvanced
Original questions designed by CodeDuel. CodeDuel is not affiliated with any publisher or certification body mentioned; certification names and trademarks belong to their respective owners and are used only to indicate the area covered. Report content
